Skinny Dipped vs Unreal Chocolate Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Showdown

The fourth in this 2025 Peanut Butter Cup Showdown is between Skinny Dipped and Unreal. I've tried several products from Unreal so I hope you go and check those out, but this series of comparisons came about because I had a good deal Skinny Dipped. I also used a coupon and Unreal was on sale when I bought and did all the testing back in March of this year before prices rose even more.

This time the two cups are very close in terms of color, thickness, radius, and the layer of peanut butter compared to the chocolate surrounding it; only the slight wave of chocolate on the top of the Unreal was a visual difference of any note. The biggest difference was that the Unreal's center was much softer and it folded when I cut through it, in fact some of the peanut butter tried to come out when I picked up a half. The fragrance is also different with the Unreal having a stronger peanut butter scent that only deadened what I got from the Skinny Dipped by comparison.

The Skinny Dipped makes a snap when I bite into it and for a few chews. The chocolate is much darker in flavor and it is so intense that it dries out my mouth by the second half of the cup. The peanut butter is roasted but not really sweet; even though I can't see them, there are tiny bits that crunch when I chew. The aftertaste is bitter as expected with little sugar added. One cup is 80 calories.

The Unreal also has 80 calories per cup. It also makes a snap when I bite into it and for a few chews. The peanut butter is the initial flavor, both roasted and sweet, but the dark chocolat builds up with each chew until it is the last and lingering of the flavors with no unpleasant aftertaste and no drying out of my mouth.

These two dark chocolate peanut butter cups are so similar in so many ways, that I thought it would be difficult to pick one until I tasted them. There is no doubt for me that I would buy and eat Unreal Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups again and again.